ProblemShop money

When your helper quits without warning

He says on Thursday that he is not coming from Monday. Settle the days, the advance, the goods and the money he collected that same evening, on paper.

The evening he tells you he is leaving

Do this the same evening

  • Write all five pieces on one page while he stands there
  • Read every line out loud so he hears the number
  • Pay whatever is left over to him before he walks out
  • Take back the keys, the delivery book and the shop phone
  • Sign one line each and keep a photo of the page

Never do this

  • Let him leave on "we will work it out later"
  • Hold his pay or his papers to force him back
  • Rebuild the days worked from memory a week afterwards
  • Argue about it at a full counter in front of customers
Both problems land together: nobody behind the counter on Monday, and money that is half finished. Only one of them gets harder every hour you wait.

He tells you on a Thursday evening that he is not coming from Monday. Settle everything that same evening, on paper, with him standing in front of you. Days worked, advance taken, goods off the shelf, money he collected, keys he holds. Every hour after he walks out turns the numbers into memory against memory.

Two problems arrive in the same sentence

Half past nine on a Thursday. The shutter is half down and Sajid is wiping the counter, the way he has for fourteen months. He does not look up. "Uncle, I have found work at the plaza. I will not come from Monday."

You say what everybody says. "Monday? Give me two weeks at least." He shrugs. He is not being cruel. He was offered the job three days ago and has been trying to say this since Tuesday.

Two problems just landed together. On Monday morning there is nobody behind the counter except you. The second is quieter and costs more: the money between you is half finished. Eighteen days of the running month are worked and unpaid. An advance left your hand on the 5th. He has been taking flour and oil off the shelf against his pay. He collected cash from a customer that you never saw. He has a key, the delivery book, and the old shop phone.

Hiring somebody solves the first problem. The second only gets harder. Tonight you both remember the same numbers. In three weeks you remember one set and he remembers another, and neither of you is lying.

The five pieces of a final settlement

Every settlement with a helper is made of the same five pieces. Write them as five lines on one page, in this order.

The days he worked in the part month. Take the monthly pay, divide by the days in the month, multiply by the days he actually worked.

The advance he already took. Whatever you handed him before pay day comes straight off the top.

Goods he took off the shelf against pay. The oil, the sack of flour, the tea. Shopkeepers forget this piece most often, because it never felt like money at the time.

Money he collected on your behalf. Any udhaar he recovered from a customer that never reached the galla, your cash drawer. Check three weeks of collections against what actually went in.

Things he holds that are not money. Keys, the delivery book, the shop phone, the padlock for the store room, the crate deposit slip. No rupees attached, and it still belongs on the page.

Say his pay was Rs 28,000 a month and he worked 18 days

Full month at Rs 28,000, so Rs 933 a dayRs 28,000
18 days worked, marked on the attendance pageRs 16,800
Advance handed to him on the 5thRs 12,000
Flour, oil and tea taken off the shelf against payRs 3,900
Collected from a customer, never put in the gallaRs 2,600
Nothing left to pay him, and this much owed by himRs 1,700
An example, not a real helper. Four of these five lines were written on the days they happened. Only the last one had to be found, and that is the one that starts fights.

Nothing is left to pay him, and Rs 1,700 sits on his side. That is the normal outcome once an advance was taken and goods went off the shelf, and it is exactly where partings turn sour.

You have three honest ways to close it, and you pick one out loud, tonight. Forgive it plainly: "Leave the 1,700, we are clear." Take it back in goods if something is still unopened. Or write a date and take it in two parts.

What you do not do is leave it open. An undecided number gives him a reason to avoid you and you a reason to keep the anger alive. And whatever the figure, you never keep his identity card and never hold his pay to force him back.

Sit down, say the number out loud, both keep a copy

Not at the counter at seven, with customers waiting. Do it after the shutter is down, or on a Sunday morning, at the back where you can both sit.

Put the page between you and read each line aloud with its number. He hears "eighteen days, Rs 16,800" and "advance on the 5th, Rs 12,000" from your own mouth, and he can stop you on any line while it is still cheap to fix.

Then write one closing line in plain words and both sign it. "Sajid's account with the shop is settled in full. Rs 1,700 remained on his side and has been forgiven. Nothing is owed either way." Two signatures, and each of you photographs the page. The matter is shut.

If anything is owed to him, pay it there and then, even while you are annoyed with him for leaving you short-handed. An unpaid balance keeps him tied to your shop: he comes back, he sends his brother, he tells it at the tea stall, and the amount grows in every retelling. Paying buys you a man who says you dealt straight, which is worth real money the next time you hire.

Start your digital khata today

Free to start. Works offline. English, Roman Urdu & Hinglish. Your customers get their app free, forever.

The part-month days, and the argument that never happens

Here is the fight, almost word for word. He says he worked twenty days. You say seventeen. Neither of you has anything but memory, and you are both counting backwards on a Thursday night, tired and annoyed.

At Rs 28,000 a month, one day is Rs 933. Three disputed days are Rs 2,800. Big enough that neither side concedes, small enough that fighting over it is stupid.

The argument disappears if attendance was marked daily. Not written up at the end, marked on the day: present, absent, half day. Then nobody remembers anything, you count marks. If he came at noon on the fourteenth, the mark says half day, because you agreed it on the fourteenth and not on the last evening.

Decide the small rules once, at hiring. Does a half day count as half pay? Does Sunday come into the divide? Ten seconds of clarity when he joins saves a bad hour when he goes, the same habit that keeps a helper's salary and advance straight all year.

The handover that has nothing to do with money

Ten days after Sajid left, the shop phone rings at six in the morning. It is the bread supplier's man, asking for Sajid. He drops trays daily and takes his money every Saturday, and Sajid counted the trays and agreed the rate. You do not know the rate. You do not know whether Saturday was paid.

That is the other half of a sudden departure, and it costs nothing until it costs you.

What he knows and you do not: ask before he goes

  • Which customers dealt only with him, and what they owe
  • Any udhaar he gave while you were out and never entered
  • Suppliers who ring his number instead of yours
  • Rates he agreed with a supplier that you never wrote down
  • Goods already ordered that have not arrived yet
  • Where the spare key, the ladder and the slow stock sit
  • Empty crates and bottles owed back to a supplier
Ask these while he is still standing in your shop. On day three he answers. On day forty he says he does not remember, and he may even be telling the truth.

A helper takes four kinds of knowledge with him. Customers he alone dealt with, whose faces he knew and whose pages you never opened. Suppliers who ring his number because he always picked up. Udhaar he gave while you were at a wedding, meant to enter and did not, exactly the way udhaar goes missing in a busy shop. And plain shop geography: the spare key, the second store room, the shelf carrying stock that never moves.

So give yourself two days after he goes and walk your own khatas. Open every customer page, not the ten you know by heart. Ring the largest balances and confirm the figure with the customer himself, gently, as a routine check and not an accusation. Count the shelves, and count the cash the way you would on any end-of-day cash reckoning. Do it before the next man starts.

Why people leave suddenly, and the two you can fix

Some reasons are not yours. He is moving city, or his father wants him in the family business, or he got fixed hours and a Sunday off. Do not take those personally.

Two reasons are yours, and both are free to fix.

The first is money that arrives late or in unpredictable pieces. Rs 5,000 on the 3rd, Rs 8,000 on the 11th, the rest whenever the shop feels flush. You may be paying the full amount over the month, but he cannot tell his household when money comes, and a man in that position starts listening to offers. Fixing it costs nothing: the same money, leaving on the same date.

The second is never knowing where he stands. He carries no running total of what he took as an advance and what is left, so he guesses. Guessing low, pay day feels like being cheated. Guessing high, pay day is a shock. Either way he stops trusting the arrangement, and a man who does not trust it leaves without warning. Show him his own page once a month, out loud, for one minute.

Setting up the next one so this evening is easy

You will hire again, whether that was the plan or not, and the choice itself is laid out in hire a helper or run the shop alone. Assume you hire. Then all of the above becomes a five-minute job at the end.

Set the next helper up so this evening is a five-minute job

  1. 1Open a page for him on the day he startsHis pay, the date it is paid, and the day he joined, written once.
  2. 2Mark him present or absent every single dayOne tick takes two seconds and ends the part-month argument forever.
  3. 3Write every advance in front of him, the moment it leaves your hand"I will write it in the evening" is how Rs 12,000 becomes Rs 8,000 in his memory.
  4. 4Enter goods he takes off the shelf like any other entryAgree once whether he pays the counter rate or your cost rate.
  5. 5Show him his own page once a monthA helper who always knows where he stands has nothing to be shocked by.
  6. 6Never let one person be the only one who knows somethingSuppliers get your number too, and you open the shop yourself one day a week.
None of this costs money. It costs about four minutes a month, and it turns a sudden departure into a page you read out instead of a night you argue through.

None of it changes if the new helper is your nephew. Family needs the page more, not less, which is the honest trade-off in a family helper or an outsider.

If your shop lives on your phone rather than in a register, the pieces are there. In Wasoolo each helper is an employee with attendance marked per day, so the part month is a count and not a debate. An advance is written the day it is handed over and sits beside the days he worked. Team permissions mean his access to your customer pages ends the evening he does. And the settlement prints as a PDF statement, one copy each.

Start your digital khata today

Free to start. Works offline. English, Roman Urdu & Hinglish. Your customers get their app free, forever.

Common questions

He stopped coming and now he will not pick up the phone. What do I do?

Do the settlement anyway, alone, on paper, dated. Work the days out from your attendance marks, subtract the advance and the goods, write the result. Send him the figure once by message and keep the page. If he surfaces later you have a calm number, not an argument.

Can I hold his last pay until he returns my keys and the delivery book?

Ask for them at the same sitting, before anything is handed over, which is why the keys belong on the settlement page as a line of their own. Holding pay to force a man back rarely works, and the street hears his version first. Change the padlock, pay him.

He took goods worth more than the pay he had earned. Is that money gone?

Treat it as a lesson in limits, not a debt to chase. Take back anything unopened, agree a small repayment with dates if he can manage it, and forgive the rest out loud. Then cap goods-against-pay for the next helper, agreed on his first day.

He gave udhaar to customers while I was away and never wrote it down. Who pays?

You will, in practice, so aim at recovery rather than blame. Get the names out of him on the last evening while he still remembers them, then confirm each amount with the customer directly. Most admit an old balance when asked plainly.

Should I ask for a month's notice in writing when I hire somebody?

You can ask, and saying it out loud on day one does no harm. Just do not build your safety on it. A helper who wants to leave will leave, and no paper puts him behind your counter on Monday. Daily marks and a written advance protect you better.

He wants to come back two months later. Should I take him?

If the parting was clean and the work was good, yes, and he is often the cheapest hire available because he already knows your customers. Take him on the same terms as a new man for the first month: fresh page, no advance until pay day comes round once.

Start your digital khata today

Free to start. Works offline. English, Roman Urdu & Hinglish. Your customers get their app free, forever.